Our favorite restaurant off the main beach of Ile de Ngor is called Sunu Makane, Chez Seck. If you tell the guys selling boat tickets that’s where you’re headed, they’ll put you on the nicer motorboats for the ride over. (Same price – 500 cfa roundtrip.)
The food is fresh and good, the service is friendly and quick and the prices are better than the mainland (peninsuland?). We’ve tried the yassa thiof (grilled whole fish with caramelized onion sauce over rice), yassa poulet, brochettes de boeuf, brochettes de lotte, garlic sautéed shrimp and seafood pasta. All get thumbs up!
(Also, Astou is one of the THE best servers in all of Dakar!)